Baltimore Regional Cooperative Purchasing Committee (BRCPC)
Location: Baltimore, MD
Procurement Priorities: Reduce the cost per megawatt hour
Annual Savings: Approximately $11 million
The Big Picture
The Baltimore Regional Cooperative Purchasing Committee (BRCPC) serves as a centralized purchasing group for more than 21 regional public schools, community colleges, county agencies, cities and towns, and other organizations. It’s a standing committee of the Baltimore Metropolitan Council, an organization comprised of elected executives from the central Maryland region. Since 2000, BRCPC has helped local governmental agencies address one of the biggest drivers for total energy spend: how you buy it. Together, BRCPC enables businesses to combine their purchasing power and procure more advantageous contracts for electricity.
In 2005, BRCPC began to explore new ways to reduce its energy costs by adopting innovative purchasing options. It selected EnerNOC subsidiary South River Consulting to develop an effective electricity procurement strategy that took advantage of new markets and opportunities.
EnerNOC helped BRCPC combine its purchasing power and buy electricity directly from the wholesale market, rather than via traditional retail markets. This program saves BRCPC members—and their communities—more than $11 million annually.
Combining Purchasing Power to Achieve New Cost Savings
Managing and reducing energy costs are a critical responsibility of state governments and agencies. Volatile prices make procuring energy at the lowest cost even more challenging. Navigating the different market rules and getting retail providers to compete against each other is time-intensive and confusing. And rising energy costs can decimate budgets, creating shortfalls that delay other critical projects and programs, such as capital improvements or tax relief.
Many state and municipal agencies focus on energy efficiency, which provides a visible impact and incremental savings, as well as associated environmental benefits. But more agencies like BRCPC are also taking a careful look at how they purchase energy, and are looking for innovative procurement strategies that take advantage of competitive energy markets.
BRCPC is dedicated to getting the best price possible for energy, saving money, and serving taxpayers. “The more we learned about the energy markets, the more we understood the potential cost savings we could achieve by doing things differently,” says Stephen Myer, chair of the BRCPC Energy Sub-committee. However, when BRCPC began to explore its options, it found a strong need for outside experience and insights into the often mystifying rules that govern the electric markets. “We couldn’t do much better in terms of pricing and suspected that we’d be better off buying from the wholesale market,” recalls Myer. “But we needed expertise to come up with a strategy.” As part of its Strategic Energy Initiative, it selected South River Consulting, an EnerNOC company, as its energy procurement partner.
EnerNOC helped BRCPC develop a formal electricity procurement strategy that took advantage of competitive markets—and that moved the agency away from the higher rates of the retail electricity markets. As part of this new risk management strategy, participating agencies combine purchasing power, creating a large, significant energy buyer that qualifies for wholesale purchases. BRCPC buys electricity directly from the wholesale market via a competitively selected retail suppler, Pepco Energy Services. For a fee, Pepco serves as BRCPC’s licensed buyer in the wholesale electricity markets.
EnerNOC worked closely with BRCPC to create a new way of purchasing energy— helping it consolidate its purchasing power and purchase directly from the wholesale markets. EnerNOC created and developed an innovative wholesale portfolio program that identified and defined roles and responsibilities. EnerNOC also helped BRCPC interview and evaluate suppliers, and negotiate its final contract with Pepco. EnerNOC serves as a long-term partner to BRCPC, implementing BRCPC’s approved risk management strategy and providing ongoing insights and ideas that help the agency save money and manage energy more efficiently.
Throughout the process, BRCPC remained committed to learning about ever-changing energy markets, and to making changes in the way it purchased energy. EnerNOC provided the knowledge, expertise, and experience necessary to create a winning strategy. This partnership generated impressive results—significant annual savings of more than $11 million.
EnerNOC helped BRCPC achieve these impressive savings by unbundling electric supply, thereby reducing supplier margins and supplier risk premiums associated with traditional, retail-based, fixed-rate contracts. By purchasing blocks of power from the wholesale markets, BRCPC can:
- Achieve better year-to-year price stability by dollar-cost averaging its purchases over time, rather than purchasing at one point
- Obtain lower block pricing by getting bids from multiple wholesale providers
- Purchase blocks at different delivery points, reducing congestion premiums and managing congestion risk
- Purchase blocks below full requirements, avoiding risk premiums by assuming the volumetric risk, which retail suppliers pass along to cover potential price differences on quantities above or below contracted amounts
EnerNOC has enabled savings of 7.5 to 9 percent over a traditional retail approach. These savings are passed directly on to BRCPC’s many agencies—from county governments to public schools to museums.
Savings of $11 million each year is the primary benefit EnerNOC’s energy procurement services bring to BRCPC—along with a range of other powerful benefits.
A Partner for Innovative Energy Procurement
With EnerNOC, BRCPC gains a partner committed to ongoing innovation in energy procurement—providing insights and innovations that help BRCPC get the best possible pricing on electricity for more than 3,200 commercial electric accounts. “EnerNOC is an exceptional partner,” says Myer. “They’re committed to meeting our energy needs. They bring wide-ranging, value-added expertise. And they’re always available to us when we need them.” While BRCPC provides clear direction and an approved risk policy, EnerNOC implements the strategy on behalf of BRCPC. It advises the group on how and when to buy blocks of power. It also provides clear communications about energy costs and issues to all BRCPC agencies.
Eliminating Retail Middlemen
The new EnerNOC energy procurement strategy enables BRCPC to purchase electricity right off the grid, reducing energy costs and simplifying energy procurement. The unbundled wholesale portfolio devised by EnerNOC is significantly more cost-effective than a fully bundled retail approach.
Better Management and Control
BRCPC has significantly reduced exposure to the inherent ups and downs of the retail electricity market. With the EnerNOC strategy, it connects directly to more cost effective wholesale markets, and in a way that offers the agency more control over its costs and risk. It gains a professionally managed portfolio of energy—one that benefits from EnerNOC’s experience and expertise.
A New Role for the Energy Buyer
With EnerNOC’s energy procurement strategy, BRCPC redefined the role played by its energy buyer, Pepco Energy Services. Pepco buys energy and earns a fee for this service, but it doesn’t have the broader responsibilities that a more traditional approach would entail. This reduced role for Pepco results in cost savings for BRCPC.
An Award Winning Approach
In 2006, the National Institute of Governmental Purchasing (NIGP) awarded its Innovations in Public Procurement Award to BRCPC. This award recognizes the high level of innovation and accountability that BRCPC brings to purchasing electricity—and the value of the new procurement strategy developed by EnerNOC.
Working together, BRCPC and EnerNOC continue to fine tune the energy procurement strategy in response to changes in the energy markets. Overall, the success of BRCPC’s strategy has led the organization to add natural gas purchasing to its portfolio, as well as utility bill tracking. It is also considering exploring the addition of heating oil and other types of energy and fuel to its strategy. In each case, EnerNOC provides the wide-ranging energy expertise necessary to keep costs low.